Tuesday, November 3, 2026

England’s Comeback: A Reality Check and New Questions for Gareth Southgate

England advanced to the Euro 2024 quarter-finals, but not without a significant scare. Trailing Slovakia 1-0 for most of the match in Gelsenkirchen, the Three Lions were just 90 seconds away from an early exit until Jude Bellingham’s spectacular overhead kick forced extra-time. Harry Kane then secured the win in the first minute of extra-time, setting up a clash with Denmark.

Despite advancing, England’s performance against the 45th-ranked team in the FIFA world rankings raised many questions about their potential for tournament success. Here’s what the Mirror Football team had to say:

Neil Moxley This match can be classified as an ‘international get-out-of-jail’ game, but its significance will depend on the overall tournament outcome. The unconvincing group stage should have prompted introspection, yet the timid changes suggest otherwise. This narrow escape must focus their attention, as such luck is unlikely to repeat.

Mike Walters The comeback echoes David Platt’s late volley against Belgium in the 1990 World Cup. Like then, England were outplayed. Robson’s team went on to the semi-finals and returned as heroes. Southgate should note that England’s goals came from set pieces, not the tedious sideways passing. Bellingham’s equalizer could be iconic if England reaches the semi-finals or beyond.

Simon Bird This wasn’t the greatest comeback but a chaotic, lucky result. Despite poor team selection and delayed substitutions, Bellingham’s brilliance saved the day. England must now embrace winning ugly and relying on perseverance and individual brilliance. It’s not pretty, but winning is what counts.

Daniel Marsh Bellingham’s goal masked another poor England display. England’s first shot on target in the entire match highlights their struggles. Unless they win the tournament, this comeback won’t be fondly remembered. The performance was lackluster, raising doubts about their potential for success.

John Cross This was the best England comeback in 25 years of covering the team. Heading towards humiliation, Bellingham’s iconic goal saved Southgate’s reign and prevented another Iceland-like disaster. Dramatic and crucial, this moment could define Southgate’s tenure.

Neil McLeman The dramatic finish recalled England’s loss to France in Euro 2004, a game they dominated before losing in injury-time. Southgate’s repetitive tactics nearly cost them again. England got lucky against Slovakia, but this won’t last.

Megan Feringa Bellingham’s brilliance saved England, but their overall performance was dismal. Switzerland, their next opponents, are tactically astute and cohesive, unlike England. Bellingham’s moment of genius might not be enough to inspire greatness.

Alan Smith England’s poor performance against a weaker team raises concerns. Despite the dramatic comeback, confidence in winning the tournament is low. Switzerland, their next opponents, are solid and could expose England’s weaknesses.

Tommy Wathen Football is about winning, and England’s performance was frustrating given their talent. Despite the poor showing, they are in the quarter-finals and can still win the trophy. Southgate must use his substitutes better and the team needs to showcase their true potential.

Mark Jones Some may say comebacks don’t matter unless you win the tournament, but moments like Bellingham’s goal are what fans live for. Despite other teams looking more energetic and well-coached, England’s individual talent keeps their chances alive.

The dramatic win has bought England time, but significant improvements are needed for Southgate’s team to fulfill their potential and contend for the title.

Leave a Reply